Why does the state a college basketball player plays in change his NIL take-home pay?
Short answer
In Forbes's model two players valued at $5 million pay the same federal tax, yet Florida's Thomas Haugh nets about $2.88 million and St. John's Tounde Yessoufou about $2.25 million because of New York state and city taxes, a $631,000 gap. Compare offers after tax, and confirm residency and local rules with a tax professional.
Two offers show the same number and a family assumes they are equal. They are not, because tax follows geography. This guide uses the Forbes top 25 tax model to show how large the difference can be, then lists what to check before comparing schools. It is educational and not tax advice, and a tax professional should confirm any real situation.
How big can the gap between two schools get?
In Forbes's estimates, St. John's Tounde Yessoufou and Florida's Thomas Haugh both have $5 million valuations and identical federal bills. Yessoufou owes an estimated $450,000 in New York state tax and $181,000 in New York City tax, while Haugh owes nothing extra to Florida or Gainesville. Haugh nets $2.88 million and Yessoufou $2.25 million, a $631,000 gap, and Yessoufou's 50.0% effective rate is the highest in the top 25, per Forbes, via Yahoo Sports.
| Player (school) | NIL value | State and local tax | Effective rate | After tax |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thomas Haugh (Florida) | $5.00M | $0 | 37.4% | $2.88M |
| Milan Momcilovic (Kentucky) | $6.00M | $0.32M | 42.9% | $3.13M |
| Tounde Yessoufou (St. John's) | $5.00M | $0.63M | 50.0% | $2.25M |

Why do some cities add their own layer?
Local taxes stack on top of state taxes. Kentucky's state rate fell to 3.5% this year, but Lexington and Louisville each levy an occupational license fee on net earnings, per Forbes. For Momcilovic that local layer adds about $128,000 on top of about $196,000 in state tax. The methodology notes list Lexington at 2.25%, Louisville at 2.2% and Monroe County, Indiana at 2.14%.
Forbes also finds ten of its top 25 play in no-income-tax states such as Texas, Florida, Tennessee or Washington, up from three in 2025-26, with Texas accounting for five. Arkansas is the only income-tax state it says exempts NIL from state tax, and a Mississippi bill stalled in the Senate.
What taxes apply to every player no matter where?
Federal rules do not change by state. Forbes treats NIL as gross income, athletes as independent contractors and the income as subject to a 15.3% self-employment tax, with a 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax above $200,000, per Forbes. It also says athletes generally cannot claim the qualified business income deduction, and that they generally avoid the "jock tax" because NIL is not tied to games played in a given state.
Players and parents new to how NIL income is set up can start with the College NIL and Revenue Share Starter Kit.
The full federal framework is in the NIL tax guide, and quarterly dates are in the 2026 tax calendar.
What do the estimates leave out?
A lot. Forbes assumes a single filer with no dependents or other income, a 5% business expense allowance, no property or sales taxes and all NIL received in 2026, per Forbes. A real player may be a resident of one state while attending school in another, may receive money across two calendar years or may have deductible costs. Timing also matters, because a 2026 tax bill covers money received January 1 through December 31, not the 2026-27 season.
Agents notice that families fix on a single number for a decision that needs three: the headline, the guaranteed portion and the after-tax result.

How should a family compare offers across states?
- Write each offer as a gross figure with payment dates by calendar year.
- Ask a tax professional to estimate state and local tax for the player's actual residency.
- Put the after-tax figure beside the guaranteed portion, not the headline.
- Add costs that vary by location, such as housing, and check whether the school offers tax education.
The offer comparison guide shows how to line these up, and the Kindle edition or paperback of The Basketball Pathway Field Guide includes a worksheet for it.
Sources
- Forbes via Yahoo Sports: Breaking down the top 25 college basketball stars' 2026 NIL tax bills
- The Basketball Pathway Field Guide, Kindle edition, Amazon
- The Basketball Pathway Field Guide, paperback, Amazon
Data current as of November 9, 2026. Figures are linked where each one appears. Leagues and regulators update these rules; check the source before relying on a number.
Related questions

